Skip to content

What Can I Substitute for Lemon Pepper Seasoning: Flavorful Alternatives

What Can I Substitute for Lemon Pepper Seasoning?

If you don’t have lemon pepper seasoning on hand, there are several substitutes you can use to achieve a similar flavor profile.

Fresh lemon zest and black pepper can be combined for a homemade substitute, while lime and black pepper can also create a citrus-forward taste.

Sumac, a Middle Eastern spice with a warm citrus flavor, can be used as a substitute as well.

Other options include using lemon juice or lemon juice powder, dried herbs such as Italian seasoning or garlic powder, or lemon curry powder for a different twist on the flavor.

Ultimately, fresh lemon with cracked black pepper can also provide the desired flavor profile.

Quick Tips and Facts:

1. Did you know that lemon zest and black pepper can be combined to create a perfect substitute for lemon pepper seasoning? Simply grate the outer yellow skin of a lemon and mix it with freshly ground black pepper to achieve a similar zesty and tangy flavor.

2. If you’re out of lemon pepper seasoning, try using sumac as a replacement. Sumac is a Middle Eastern spice made from dried, crushed berries. It offers a tangy, lemon-like flavor and can be used in the same proportions as lemon pepper seasoning.

3. Another interesting alternative to lemon pepper seasoning is using dried lemon verbena leaves and crushed black peppercorns. Lemon verbena has a citrusy flavor that closely resembles lemon zest, and combining it with freshly ground black pepper can mimic the taste of lemon pepper seasoning.

4. If you don’t have lemon pepper seasoning on hand, you can make a simple DIY version by combining equal parts of lemon juice concentrate and ground black pepper. Mix them together thoroughly and use the mixture as a substitute in your recipes.

5. In case you prefer a milder, less tangy alternative to lemon pepper seasoning, using a combination of garlic powder and freshly ground white pepper can be a great option. This substitution will give your dishes a subtle and savory flavor, perfect for those who prefer a less citrusy taste.

Fresh Lemon Zest And Black Pepper

Lemon pepper seasoning is a popular spice blend that adds a bright and citrusy flavor to dishes. But what if you don’t have it on hand and need a substitute? One option is to create your own by combining fresh lemon zest and black pepper.

To make this substitute, simply grate the zest from a lemon using a fine grater or zester. Combine the lemon zest with an equal amount of freshly ground black pepper, and mix them together thoroughly. The fresh lemon zest will provide the citrus flavor, while the black pepper adds a hint of spice and depth.

This homemade lemon pepper seasoning substitute can be used in any recipe that calls for the store-bought version. It works well as a rub for grilled meats, a seasoning for roasted vegetables, or a topping for popcorn. The combination of the bright lemon flavor and the aromatic black pepper will add a delicious zing to your dishes.

Lime And Black Pepper

If you don’t have lemons on hand but happen to have limes, you can easily create a substitute for lemon pepper seasoning using lime and black pepper.

To make this substitute, zest a lime using a fine grater or zester, just like you would with a lemon. Combine the lime zest with an equal amount of freshly ground black pepper, and mix them together thoroughly. The lime zest will provide a slightly different citrus flavor compared to lemon, but it will still give your dishes a bright and tangy taste. The black pepper will add a subtle spicy kick.

This lime and black pepper substitute can be used in the same way as the lemon zest and black pepper substitute. Try it as a seasoning for grilled fish, a marinade for chicken, or a topping for roasted potatoes. The lime flavor will add a refreshing twist to your dishes.

  • Zest a lime using a fine grater or zester
  • Combine lime zest and freshly ground black pepper
  • Mix thoroughly
  • Use as seasoning for grilled fish, marinade for chicken, or topping for roasted potatoes.

This lime and black pepper substitute can be used in the same way as the lemon zest and black pepper substitute. Try it as a seasoning for grilled fish, a marinade for chicken, or a topping for roasted potatoes. The lime flavor will add a refreshing twist to your dishes.

Purchasing Lemon Pepper Spice

If you frequently use lemon pepper seasoning, it’s a good idea to consider purchasing a large container of it. This ensures that you always have it on hand and saves you time and effort from making substitutes. Additionally, buying in bulk or opting for larger containers is a cost-effective option that can save you money in the long run. You can find lemon pepper spice at most grocery stores or online. When choosing a brand, look for one that offers a good balance of citrus and peppery flavors.

Sumac As A Substitute

If you’re looking for a substitute that offers a unique twist on lemon pepper seasoning, consider using sumac. Sumac is a popular spice in the Middle East and has a warm citrus flavor that can be used as a substitute for lemon pepper.

Sumac is made from ground sumac berries, which have a tangy and slightly sweet taste. It adds a vibrant red color and a distinct citrusy flavor to dishes. When combined with black pepper, it can provide a similar flavor profile to lemon pepper seasoning.

To use sumac as a substitute, simply mix it with an equal amount of freshly ground black pepper. Sprinkle this mixture onto grilled meats, roasted vegetables, or even salads. The combination of sumac and black pepper will give your dishes a unique and flavorful twist.

Lime Juice Or Zest With Black Pepper

Another option for substituting lemon pepper seasoning is to use lime juice or zest along with black pepper. Depending on the dish you are preparing, you can choose either the juice or zest to achieve the desired flavor profile.

If you want a pronounced citrus flavor, go with lime juice. Squeeze the juice of a lime and mix it with an equal amount of freshly ground black pepper. This combination will give your dishes a tangy and zesty taste.

If you prefer a more subtle citrus flavor, opt for lime zest instead. Grate the zest of a lime using a fine grater or zester and combine it with an equal amount of black pepper. The lime zest will add a fragrant and refreshing note to your dishes.

Both the lime juice and zest with black pepper substitutes can be used in various recipes. Use the lime juice substitute as a marinade for chicken or seafood, or drizzle it over grilled vegetables. The lime zest substitute works well as a seasoning for rice dishes, pasta, or even desserts like lemon bars or muffins.

Lemon Thyme And Black Pepper

If you’re looking for a substitute that goes beyond just citrus flavors, consider using lemon thyme and black pepper. Lemon thyme is an herb with a strong lemony aroma and taste, making it an excellent alternative to lemon pepper seasoning.

To make this substitute, crush and mix equal amounts of dried lemon thyme leaves and black pepper. The lemon thyme will provide a distinctive lemon flavor, while the black pepper will add a hint of heat and complexity.

This substitute can be used in any recipe that calls for lemon pepper seasoning. It works well as a rub for roasted chicken, a seasoning for grilled vegetables, or a flavor enhancer for soups and stews. The lemon thyme and black pepper combination will give your dishes a fresh and herbaceous twist.


In conclusion, if you find yourself without lemon pepper seasoning, there are plenty of flavorful alternatives you can use. From fresh lemon zest and black pepper to lime juice or zest with black pepper, and even unique substitutes like sumac or lemon thyme and black pepper, you have a range of options to choose from. Experiment with these substitutes to add a burst of citrusy flavor to your favorite dishes.

  • Fresh lemon zest and black pepper
  • Lime juice or zest with black pepper
  • Sumac
  • Lemon thyme and black pepper

Frequently Asked Questions

What is lemon pepper seasoning made of?

Lemon pepper seasoning is typically composed of dried lemon zest, pepper, and salt. However, some variations may also include garlic and/or onion powder. Personally, I find the simplicity of the lemon and pepper combination to be the most appealing. It is important to check the label of store-bought lemon pepper as it may contain other additional ingredients that might not be desired.

Can you substitute lemon juice for lemon pepper seasoning?

Yes, you can substitute lemon juice for lemon pepper seasoning in most recipes. Lemon pepper seasoning is a combination of lemon zest and black pepper, so using freshly squeezed lemon juice along with ground black pepper can provide a similar flavor profile. It’s important to note that adding a small amount of salt can help balance the flavors and mimic the taste of lemon pepper seasoning more effectively. By using this homemade substitution, you can still achieve a tangy and slightly spicy taste in your dish.

What tastes like lemon pepper?

In search of a taste similar to lemon pepper? Look no further than lemon thyme, a herb that offers a refreshing and intricate profile to elevate your culinary creations. To achieve the desired lemon pepper flavor, double the amount of lemon thyme in your recipe. For an added twist, consider blending lemon thyme with black pepper for a delightful combination of zesty and peppery notes.

What does lemon pepper do to food?

Lemon pepper enhances the flavor of food with its unique combination of zesty citrus and spicy black pepper. Its vibrant burst of citrus adds a refreshing tang to your dishes, while the piney black pepper adds a subtle heat. Whether used as a dry rub or sprinkled on top, this homemade lemon pepper adds a delightful oomph, elevating the taste of seafood, poultry, and vegetables to new heights.

Share this post on social!